Last year, your organization appointed approximately 30 distributors across Gujarat and Rajasthan. There was a hike in primary turnover by 35%, and the monthly billing was satisfactory. However, the distributors had severe issues after a certain period, and six of them stopped placing orders.
Did you figure out where you went wrong? If you think that product demand is the root cause of losing distributors, you might be wrong. Sometimes it has been observed that the problem can be profitability, and that is the reason why distributors are unable to place orders.
A number of Indian SMEs assess the performance of their distribution channels based on sales and distributors. However, in most cases, these figures do not show whether these distributors are really earning. This is why the concept of distributor ROI comes into play. Analyzing your distributors’ profits relative to their investment will help you in the future.
The distributor ROI evaluates the revenue a distributor generates relative to the invested capital in your business. Distributors use money on inventory, warehousing, transport, people, and credit for retailers. Even if sales are high, these investments must yield adequate returns for the profitability of the business.
Let’s take an example of a distributor having average capital employed of ₹20 lakh and net operating profit of ₹4 lakh per year. In this case, the calculation is:
Distributor ROI = (₹4,00,000 ÷ ₹20,00,000) × 100 = 20%
This indicates that the distributor yields an operating ROI of 20% per annum on capital invested. The critical issue is not just about being profitable but whether the return justifies the effort, investment, and risks associated. For businesses concentrating on channel partner management in India, ROI analysis enables detection of underperforming distributors before they quit the product brand.
Sometimes the distributors overcome financial hardships even after achieving their revenue target. The difficulty often lies in the operational procedures of the distribution business. Here are the reasons why distributors struggle with profitability:
Distributors rarely maintain more stock than is required by the market. Slow moving goods capture the warehouse space and restrict working capital that could encourage faster selling goods.
It might be the situation that the retailers receive a one-month credit but can delay payments beyond the period of agreement. In the meantime, the distributors should purchase inventory and pay operating costs. Later on, there can be pressure on working capital.
Transportation, warehouse, and other miscellaneous expenses might lower the distributor margins. Profitability is hampered if there is no appropriate cost monitoring and route planning.
Even though there is strong primary billing, there will not necessarily be strong retail buying. The failure to sell off the goods leads to fewer repeat orders and capital getting tied up in stock. Knowing these challenges is the first step in making the process of increasing distributor profitability more effective.
One of the most common mistakes companies make is to judge the distributors based only on their primary sales. To analyze the actual market movement, businesses need to become familiar with primary vs secondary sales.
| Primary Sales | Secondary Sales |
| Sales from manufacturer to distributor | Sales from distributor to retailers |
| Reflects company billing | Reflects downstream product movement |
| Helps assess manufacturer revenue | Helps assess distributor stock movement |
| May increase without retail demand | Indicates the distributor’s ability to serve retail demand |
The situation is that a manufacturer’s total bill is coming to 20 lakh worth of product to a distributor each month. However, the distributor can sell only a sum of 15 lakh to the retailer, which is not an appropriate indication. The remaining 5 lakh is added to the inventory with no other stock adjustments.
After a certain period, this creates excess inventory, increases carrying expenses, and decreases available working capital. Companies should at least pay more attention to primary and secondary sales together, as it makes them familiar with the actual distribution performance.
To improve distributor ROI, businesses should not only consider increasing sales targets as their sole priority. Operating efficiency, inventory, market coverage, and working capital are a few factors that cannot be compromised. Here are the five practical stages to improve distributor profitability.
Evaluate the products that generate unlimited sales and the ones that remain unsold. Classify inventory based on their selling value and contribution using ABC analysis. In addition to that, use stock ageing and sales velocity analysis to detect slow moving products. This would lead to better inventory planning with minimum capital investment.
More distributors do not necessarily result in better market penetration. Companies should look into the effectiveness of their current distributors in serving their retailers. Monitor the number of active retail stores, orders placed, average size of order, and the sales call percentage made that result in orders. For instance, if a salesperson makes calls to 40 retail stores but gets an order from only 12, he/she has a 30% effective sales call percentage.
Credit management impacts the profit making of distributors directly. Companies need to create clear credit policies for their retailers, check payment arrears, and monitor outstanding debts. A company that sells 40 lakh per month, facing arrears in collections from the retailers, can be more cash flow burdened than one selling 30 lakh. Debtor, inventory, and payable days are the elements of the cash conversion cycle. Reduction of the cash conversion cycle generates working capital.
Remember that the best sales figures are not an indicator of higher revenue. It is for manufacturers to assess if distributors’ margins compensate for the costs involved in transportation, storage, labour, financing, and other costs. Take the example of a distributor making 50 lakh a month in sales with a gross margin of 8%. This gives a gross profit of ₹4 lakh. But when monthly operational costs amount to 3.5 lakh, only 50,000 is left as an operational profit. Instead of giving more discounts, companies need to find ways to make deliveries more efficient.
Performance tracking and regular reviews must be introduced to increase distributor profitability based on performance measurement. Operational indicators should be reviewed weekly and financial performance monthly.
Profitability for the distributor starts even before the first sale. A poor distributor appointment process can lead to issues that may not be easy to fix at a later stage. Businesses should analyze potential distributors based on financial stability, retail connections, warehousing facilities, category experience, and geographical reach.
But more importantly, manufacturers must check whether the proposed territory provides enough sales potential to justify the investments made by the distributor. And here comes the need for formal distribution network consulting. Market mapping, territory planning, margin analysis, and channel diagnostics help design distribution networks based on commercial viability rather than appointments.
Increasing distributor return on investment does not mean selling more and more products through the distribution channel. It means ensuring that every distributor makes money from sales while assisting the manufacturer in increasing market coverage. Inventory optimization, secondary sales monitoring, working capital management, and higher sales productivity are important to accomplish the task.
For Indian small and medium enterprises, The White Lotusconsultant provides services for retail and distribution. It includes market mapping, distribution analysis, inventory optimization, sales force productivity, and growth strategy. With appropriate processes and performance metrics, businesses can establish good relationships and form an effective distribution channel.
1. How can companies improve distributor return on investment?
Companies can improve the return on investment for their distributors by minimizing extra stock, boosting secondary sales, enhancing product retail coverage, managing operating costs, and handling credit collection.
2. Is there any difference between primary and secondary sales?
Primary sales are those sales that occur when manufacturers sell their products to distributors. Secondary sales are sales made by distributors to retailers or dealers.
3. What are the key KPIs for distributor profitability?
Key KPIs include distributor return on investment, inventory turns, operating margins, secondary sales growth, efficiency in collections, and productive retail coverage.
4. How will distribution network consulting help India’s SMEs?
Distribution network consulting will help India’s SMEs achieve improved market reach, distributor assessment, efficient inventory management, sales effectiveness, and performance measurement.
5. Why should distributor profitability be considered by manufacturers?
Distributors who are profitable will have a better capability to manage inventory, serve retailers, build sales teams, and expand markets. When distributors are not profitable, this will cause declining orders, poor market coverage, and distributor turnover.
Enquiry
